Are Paper Checks Safe? Risks, Fraud & Better Alternatives

Why Can’t We Quit Paper Checks—and Are Scammers Cashing In?

Are paper checks safe? Even in today’s digital world, paper checks are still hanging on—but at what cost? While many people have shifted to online payments and banking apps, a surprising number still prefer the old-school checkbook. But are these outdated habits putting people at risk?

Check out the full podcast episode:

In this episode of Ask Ralph, we dive into the reasons why paper checks continue to linger, the hidden dangers they pose, and how scammers are taking advantage of them. Alongside special guest Craig Van Slyke, we explore the financial and security risks associated with writing checks, plus offer actionable tips to protect yourself and your loved ones from fraud.

Why Do People Still Use Paper Checks?

Despite the convenience of digital payments, many people—especially older generations—still prefer to pay bills, donate to their church, and even send money to family through the mail. But why?

• Trust in Traditional Methods: Many individuals feel more comfortable using checks because they have been doing so for decades. Online banking can seem overwhelming or untrustworthy to some.

• Avoiding Digital Fraud: Ironically, some people believe checks are safer than digital transactions, fearing online scams and identity theft.

• Habit and Convenience: For some, transitioning to digital payments seems unnecessary. They know how to manage their finances with checks and see no reason to change.

The Risk of Check Fraud and Mail Theft

While checks might feel like a safe option, they can actually be one of the riskiest payment methods. Scammers have found ways to exploit them in several ways:

• Mailbox Theft: Thieves steal checks from mailboxes, wash them with chemicals to change the payee, and cash them for large amounts.

• Check Washing Scams: Criminals can alter checks with household chemicals, rewriting them to steal thousands of dollars from unsuspecting victims.

• Fake Check Schemes: Scammers send fraudulent checks and trick recipients into cashing them before realizing they are worthless, often resulting in victims owing money to the bank.

How to Protect Yourself and Your Loved Ones

If you or your loved ones still use paper checks, it’s essential to take precautions to avoid falling victim to fraud. Here are some expert tips discussed on the show:

1. Use Online Bill Pay or Direct Deposit – Encourage your elderly family members to switch to digital banking methods that offer better security.

2. Mail Checks Safely – If you must use checks, drop them off at a secure post office rather than leaving them in an unlocked mailbox.

3. Monitor Bank Statements Regularly – Keep an eye on your accounts for any suspicious transactions or unauthorized withdrawals.

4. Set Up Automatic Payments – Reduce the need for checks by setting up automatic bill payments through your bank.

5. Educate Loved Ones About Fraud – Gently inform older relatives about the dangers of check fraud and show them how to recognize scams.

Is Online Banking Actually Safer?

One of the biggest concerns among check users is the fear of online fraud. However, modern digital banking often provides more security measures than paper checks, such as:

• Real-Time Alerts: Banks notify you immediately of suspicious activity.

• Multi-Factor Authentication: Additional security layers protect your account from unauthorized access.

• Transaction Tracking: Online banking makes it easy to see where your money is going in real time.

While online banking isn’t completely risk-free, taking the right precautions—like using strong passwords and enabling fraud alerts—makes it a far safer option than mailing checks.

Final Thoughts: It’s Time to Move On

Paper checks are becoming increasingly risky in an era of sophisticated fraud schemes. While it can be difficult to break long-standing financial habits, making the transition to more secure banking methods is worth the effort. If you or someone you love still relies on checks, now is the time to discuss safer alternatives.

Want more insights on personal finance and security? Subscribe to Ask Ralph for expert advice on managing your money wisely and staying ahead of financial scams.