Jan. 24, 2025

Is GAP Insurance Essential for New Car Buyers in 2025?

Why Are New Car Owners Most at Risk for This Insurance Nightmare?

Welcome back to "Ask Ralph," your daily dose of Christian financial wisdom! Today, we're diving deep into an insurance predicament that often catches new car owners off guard: being "upside down" on your car loan. This means you owe more on your loan than the car is actually worth, and it can quickly spiral into a financial nightmare if your car is totaled or stolen. So Is GAP Insurance Essential for New Car Buyers in 2025? Let’s explore how it can protect you from these potential pitfalls and provide peace of mind in uncertain situations.

Check out the full podcast episode:

Understanding the Risk

Imagine this: you're cruising in your shiny new car, enjoying that new car smell, when suddenly, you're involved in an accident. Thankfully, you're okay, but your car is totaled. Your insurance company steps in to cover the damages, but there's a catch. Due to depreciation, your car's actual cash value (ACV) is now significantly less than what you still owe on your loan. This leaves you in a financial gap, potentially owing thousands of dollars out of pocket.

This scenario is all too common for new car owners. Why? Because new cars depreciate rapidly, especially in the first year¹. In fact, studies show that nearly 1 in 4 Americans who financed a new car purchase and traded in a vehicle had negative equity on their previous loan in the second quarter of 2024². That number jumps to 39% for vehicles purchased since 2022, highlighting the vulnerability of new car buyers³. More than 1 in 5 consumers with negative equity owe more than $10,000 on their auto loans⁴!

But the risks of being upside down on your auto loan extend beyond accidents. What if you can't keep up with the payments and need to downsize to a cheaper car? Or perhaps your lifestyle changes, and you need to swap your two-seater for a family van? ⁵ In these situations, negative equity can make it difficult to get out of your current loan and into a more suitable vehicle. You'll be stuck with that debt, even if you no longer have the car.

And here's another potential pitfall: if you trade in your car while upside down, you could end up rolling that negative equity into a new loan, making your situation even worse⁶. It's a cycle that can be difficult to break free from.

GAP Insurance to the Rescue

GAP insurance, or Guaranteed Asset Protection insurance, is designed to bridge this financial gap. It's an optional coverage that can be a lifesaver for those who finance or lease their vehicles. Here's how it works:

You purchase GAP insurance: This can be done through your auto insurer or the dealership.
Your car is totaled or stolen: A covered incident occurs, and your car is declared a total loss.
Your primary insurance pays the ACV: Your comprehensive or collision coverage will reimburse you for the current market value of your car.
GAP insurance covers the difference: If the ACV is less than your outstanding loan balance, GAP insurance steps in to cover the remaining amount, minus any deductible⁷.

Essentially, GAP insurance protects you from the financial burden of depreciation in the event of a total loss. It ensures that you don't end up owing money on a car you can no longer drive¹. It's important to note that GAP insurance only covers vehicle losses and doesn't cover bodily injuries, medical expenses, or other costs associated with an accident¹.

Real-Life Examples

Let's say you buy a new car and finance $25,000. A year later, you're involved in an accident, and your car is totaled. Unfortunately, due to depreciation, your car is now only worth $15,000, but you still owe $20,000 on your loan. Your primary auto insurance would pay out $15,000, leaving you with a $5,000 gap to fill. This is where GAP insurance comes in. It would cover that $5,000 difference (minus any deductible), preventing you from having to pay that amount out of pocket¹.

Alternatives to GAP Insurance

While GAP insurance is a valuable tool, there are alternatives to consider:

Larger down payment: A significant down payment reduces the loan amount and minimizes the risk of negative equity.
Shorter loan term: A shorter loan term means you'll pay off the car faster and build equity more quickly.
Loan/lease payoff coverage: This is similar to GAP insurance but differs in a few key ways. First, unlike GAP insurance, which is typically only available for new cars, you can often obtain loan/lease payoff coverage for both new and used vehicles⁸. Second, while GAP insurance covers the full difference between the car's ACV and the loan balance, loan/lease payoff coverage may only cover a percentage of that difference, potentially leaving you with some out-of-pocket expenses⁸.

Cost and Considerations

The cost of GAP insurance varies depending on where you purchase it.

Through your insurer: Adding GAP coverage to your existing auto policy is generally the most affordable option, typically costing around $20 to $40 per year⁹.
Through the dealership: Dealerships and lenders often charge higher prices for GAP insurance than car insurance companies⁹. They usually offer it at a flat fee between $500 and $700, which is added to your loan amount¹⁰. This means you'll be paying interest on the GAP coverage throughout the loan term.

When deciding if GAP insurance is right for you, consider the following:

Loan-to-value ratio: Are you financing a large portion of the car's value?
Loan term: Do you have a long loan term (five years or more)?
Depreciation rate: How quickly does the car model you're purchasing typically depreciate?
Vehicle Value: More expensive cars might have higher GAP insurance costs¹¹.

If you answered yes to the first three questions, and you're purchasing a more expensive vehicle, GAP insurance might be a wise investment.

It's also worth noting that you may be able to purchase GAP insurance after you've already bought a car¹². Some insurers require your vehicle to be brand new, meaning you're the original owner and the vehicle isn't older than two or three model years¹². Check with your insurer to see what their specific qualifications are.

Biblical Principles of Stewardship

As Christian stewards, we are called to manage our finances wisely and responsibly. Proverbs 21:5 reminds us, "The plans of the diligent lead surely to advantage, but everyone who is hasty comes surely to poverty." ¹³ Investing in GAP insurance can be seen as an act of diligence, protecting ourselves from potential financial hardship.

Furthermore, 1 Timothy 6:17 cautions us against putting our hope in wealth, which is uncertain. Instead, we should put our hope in God, who richly provides for us¹⁴. GAP insurance can provide peace of mind, knowing that we are prepared for unexpected events and not solely relying on material possessions.

Conclusion

New car owners are particularly vulnerable to the financial risks of negative equity due to rapid depreciation. GAP insurance offers a safety net, protecting you from potentially owing thousands of dollars if your car is totaled or stolen. By understanding the benefits and costs of GAP insurance, and considering alternatives, you can make an informed decision that brings you peace of mind.

I encourage you to take some time to assess your own needs and explore GAP insurance options. Talk to your insurance agent or financial advisor to get personalized advice. And if you have any questions or experiences to share about GAP insurance, please leave a comment below or reach out to us on the "Ask Ralph" podcast! Remember, God calls us to be wise and responsible with our resources, and making informed decisions about our finances is an important part of that calling.

Works cited

Gap Insurance Coverage: What Is It? | Liberty Mutual, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.libertymutual.com/vehicle/auto-insurance/coverage/gap-coverage
Nearly 1 in 4 Americans Who Financed a New Car Purchase with a Trade-in During Q2 Were Upside Down on Their Loan, According to Edmunds, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.edmunds.com/industry/press/nearly-1-in-4-americans-who-financed-a-new-car-purchase-with-a-trade-in-during-q2-were-upside-down-on-their-loan-according-to-edmunds.html
New Survey: 1 in 3 Drivers Are Underwater, Most Overestimate Their Car's Value - CarEdge, accessed January 15, 2025, https://caredge.com/guides/caredge-black-book-negative-equity-report-q3-2024
Negative Equity on the Rise: The Average Amount Owed on Upside-Down Car Loans Hit an All-Time High in Q3 2024, According to Edmunds, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.edmunds.com/industry/press/negative-equity-on-the-rise-the-average-amount-owed-on-upside-down-car-loans-hit-an-all-time-high-in-q3-2024-according-to-edmunds.html
Is Your Car Loan Upside-Down? How to Handle Negative Equity - NerdWallet, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/loans/auto-loans/car-loans-upside-down
How to Deal With an Upside-Down Car Loan - Experian, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.experian.com/blogs/ask-experian/how-to-get-out-of-an-upside-down-car-loan/
What Is Gap Insurance and How Does It Work? - Progressive, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.progressive.com/answers/gap-insurance/
Everything You Need to Know About the Best Gap Insurance - Car and Driver, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.caranddriver.com/car-insurance/a36280399/best-gap-insurance/
How Much Is GAP Insurance: Everything You Need to Know - Car and Driver, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.caranddriver.com/car-insurance/a36534152/how-much-is-gap-insurance/
Gap Insurance Cost: A Full Guide For 2023 - Agency Height, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.agencyheight.com/gap-insurance-cost/
How Much is Gap Insurance? | Joe Basil Chevrolet, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.joebasilchevrolet.com/finance/car-buying-tips/how-much-is-gap-insurance/
What Is Gap Insurance? - Car - Allstate, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.allstate.com/resources/car-insurance/gap-insurance-coverage
Bible Verses About Money and Stewardship - Envoy Financial, accessed January 15, 2025, https://www.envoyfinancial.com/bible-verses-about-money-and-stewardship/
10 Bible Verses About Stewardship of Money - Tithe.ly, accessed January 15, 2025, https://get.tithe.ly/blog/bible-verses-about-stewardship-of-money

Ralph V. Estep, Jr.

Christian Financial Consulting

Ralph V. Estep, Jr. is a highly accomplished professional with a diverse background in finance, accounting, technology, and entrepreneurship. As the principal at Saggio Management Group, Inc., he has demonstrated exceptional leadership and expertise in various roles throughout his career.

Ralph's educational journey began at St. Mark's High School in Newark, Delaware before attending the University of Nebraska where he was an esteemed member of the Cornhusker Marching Band and had the privilege of performing at the Florida Citrus Bowl in Orlando.

Continuing his pursuit of knowledge and excellence, Ralph earned a Bachelor of Science Degree in Accounting from the University of Delaware. He further expanded his academic achievements by obtaining a Master's in Business Administration from Wilmington University.

Throughout his professional journey, Ralph has been recognized for his outstanding accomplishments and commitment to excellence. He is a member of prestigious organizations such as the Golden Key National Honor Society and Beta Gamma Sigma International Business Honor Society.

With an extensive range of professional designations including Licensed Public Accountant (LPA), Accredited Business Accountant (ABA), Accredited Tax Advisor (ATA), Accredited Tax Preparer (ATP), and Internal Revenue Service Registered Tax Preparer (RTRP), Ralph possesses comprehensive expertise in tax preparation and financial management.

Beyond his impressive qualifications, Ralph has actively engaged with various community programs as bo… Read More

What Steps Should I Take If I’m Locked Out of E-Filing?

Locked Out of E-filing? The Secret PIN That Changes Everything! Have you ever been ready to e-file your taxes, only to be stopped in your tracks by a missing PIN? It can be frustrating, especially when you're trying to get your taxes done on time a…

Why Might I Not Feel Close to God Anymore Despite Regular Worship?

Ask Ralph: Why Don't I Feel Close to God Anymore? Welcome back to “Ask Ralph,” your daily dose of Christian finance wisdom! Today, we tackle a question that goes beyond the balance sheet and straight to the heart: "Why don't I feel clos…