Is DIY Tax Filing Worth the Risk?

Overwhelmed by Tax Prep? How to Decide Between Software and an Accountant with Confidence

Tax season. Those two little words can strike fear into the hearts of many. As Christians, we want to be good stewards of our resources and fulfill our obligations, but the complexities of the tax code can feel overwhelming. Proverbs 13:11 reminds us that "Dishonest money dwindles away, but whoever gathers money little by little makes it grow." This wisdom applies not only to our earnings but also to how we manage our tax responsibilities. Should you brave the DIY route with tax software or seek the guidance of a professional accountant? Is DIY Tax Filing Worth the Risk? Those are the question we'll tackle in this blog post, offering biblical wisdom and practical advice to help you make the decision with confidence. 

Check out the full podcast episode:

Understanding the Options

Before diving into the pros and cons, let's clarify what each option entails.

Tax Software: Companies like TurboTax, H&R Block, and TaxSlayer offer user-friendly software that guides you through preparing your tax return. They ask questions about your income, expenses, and deductions, then use that information to complete the necessary forms. Many even offer audit support and accuracy guarantees¹. For example, TurboTax offers a premium service called "Audit Defense" for an additional fee, where they will handle all correspondence with the IRS if you get audited². The IRS recommends filing electronically and opting for direct deposit to expedite the process and minimize errors³.

Accountant: A professional accountant, such as a Certified Public Accountant (CPA) or Enrolled Agent (EA), brings years of experience and specialized knowledge to the table. They can provide personalized advice, identify potential deductions you might miss, and represent you in case of an audit.

Tax Preparation Service: In addition to software and individual accountants, you can also outsource your tax preparation to companies like Cogneesol. These companies specialize in providing expert tax preparation services tailored to your needs. This can be a good option for those who want professional assistance but prefer a more streamlined and potentially cost-effective approach⁴.

Pros and Cons: A Balanced Perspective

Both tax software and accountants have advantages and disadvantages. Let's weigh them carefully:

Tax Software

Pros:

• Cost-Effective: Tax software is generally less expensive than hiring an accountant, with prices ranging from free for simple returns to around $179 for more complex situations⁵.
• Convenient: File your taxes from the comfort of your home, at your own pace⁶.
• Fast: Many users can complete their returns in just a few hours⁶.
• User-Friendly: Most software options have intuitive interfaces and step-by-step instructions³.
• Accuracy: Sophisticated algorithms help minimize errors and ensure compliance with tax laws⁷.

Cons:

• Limited Support: Software can't replace the personalized advice of a human expert⁶.
• Potential for Errors: Incorrect data entry or misunderstanding questions can lead to mistakes⁶.
• No Tax Planning: Software focuses on filing current-year taxes, not long-term strategies⁶.
• May Not Be Suitable for Complex Situations: If your finances are complicated, software might not be sufficient and could lead to missed write-offs or incorrect income reporting⁸.

Accountant

Pros:

• Expertise: Accountants have in-depth knowledge of tax laws and can identify potential savings⁹.
• Time-Saving: They handle the entire process, freeing you to focus on other priorities. As Proverbs 21:20 wisely states, "The wise store up choice food and olive oil, but fools gulp theirs down." Sometimes, investing in professional help allows us to be wiser with our time and energy⁹.
• Reduced Errors: Their expertise minimizes the risk of mistakes⁹.
• Audit Assistance: They can represent you before the IRS if needed⁹.
• Personalized Advice: They can offer tailored guidance based on your unique situation¹⁰.

Cons:

• Cost: Hiring an accountant can be more expensive than using software¹¹.
• Scheduling: You'll need to schedule appointments and gather documents⁹.
• Potential for Incompetence: Not all accountants are created equal. It's important to be cautious and choose reputable preparers with credentials like CPA or EA¹².
• Dependency: Relying on a tax professional can lead to dependency, hindering individuals from learning about their own finances¹².
• Privacy Concerns: Sharing personal financial information with a tax preparer involves a level of trust. Ensure your chosen preparer maintains confidentiality¹².

Real-Life Experiences

To help you gain a better understanding of what it's like to use tax software or hire an accountant, let's hear from some people who have experienced both:

• "I always use this app to file my taxes because it is easy and helpful." - Susieq3, FreeTaxUSA user ¹³
• "Turbo tax is the best software for tax preparation on the market. I have used it for several years." - BW75, TurboTax user ¹⁴
• "Straight Talk CPAs has Provided $100,000 in Benefits to Me and My Business! Since the first year my taxes were done with Straight Talk CPAs, I felt like Salim and his team were able to find ways for me to lessen my tax burden." - Dr. Hasan Zaidi, Straight Talk CPAs client ¹⁵
• "Their attention to detail is remarkable and their tenacity, diligence, and dedication to all our needs far exceeds anything we expected. We recently had some tax complications and I never worried that it would get resolved quickly, accurately, and easily." - TAX-SAVERS client ¹⁵

These testimonials highlight the diverse experiences people have with tax preparation. While some find software to be sufficient for their needs, others appreciate the personalized guidance and expertise of a professional.

Making the Decision: A Christian Perspective

The best choice between tax software and an accountant depends heavily on your specific tax situation and personal preferences⁶. As Christians, we are called to be good stewards of our resources. This includes our time, talents, and finances. When deciding between tax software and an accountant, consider these biblical principles:

Stewardship: Are you using your time and money wisely? If preparing your taxes yourself would cause undue stress or potential errors, hiring an accountant might be a better stewardship decision¹⁶.

Wisdom: Proverbs 11:1 teaches us the importance of honesty in all our dealings, including financial matters. Seek wise counsel and make informed decisions¹⁷. This might involve consulting with trusted friends, family members, or financial advisors who can offer insights based on their own experiences.

Generosity: While taxes are an obligation, they also contribute to the common good. As we give back to society, we reflect God's generosity¹⁶.

Contentment: 1 Timothy 6:6 reminds us that "godliness with contentment is great gain." Don't let the pursuit of tax savings overshadow the importance of trusting God with your finances¹⁸.

Seeking God's Guidance: In all our financial decisions, it's essential to seek God's wisdom and direction. As Proverbs 16:1 states, "We can make our plans, but the final outcome is in God's hands." Prayerfully consider your options and ask God to lead you to the best choice for your situation¹⁹.

Prioritizing Giving: As Christians, we are called to be generous and support the work of God's Kingdom. This includes giving to our local church and other charitable causes. When making tax decisions, consider how your choices might impact your ability to give¹⁸. For example, are there certain deductions or credits that might free up more resources for giving?

Unique Tax Considerations for Christians: Christians may have unique tax considerations that influence their decision. For example, clergy members have specific rules for reporting housing allowances and self-employment income. Additionally, charitable giving plays a significant role in the lives of many Christians, and understanding the tax implications of tithing and charitable donations is essential²⁰.

When to Choose an Accountant

While tax software is a viable option for many, certain situations warrant the expertise of an accountant:

• Complex Tax Situations: If you have multiple income sources, investments, rental properties, or own a business, an accountant can help you navigate the complexities²².
• Itemizing Deductions: If you plan to itemize instead of taking the standard deduction, an accountant can ensure you maximize your eligible expenses²³.
• Life Changes: Major life events like marriage, divorce, or the birth of a child can significantly impact your taxes. An accountant can guide you through the changes²³.
• Lack of Confidence: If you feel overwhelmed by tax laws or uncomfortable handling your own taxes, an accountant can provide peace of mind²³.
• Audit Risk: If you're concerned about the possibility of an audit, an accountant can help you prepare and represent you before the IRS⁹.

Choosing the Right Type of Accountant:

When choosing an accountant, it's important to consider their specific expertise and qualifications. Here's a brief overview of the different types of tax professionals:

• Certified Public Accountants (CPAs): CPAs are licensed professionals with extensive knowledge of accounting and tax laws. They often work with businesses and individuals with complex tax situations²².
• Enrolled Agents (EAs): EAs are federally authorized tax practitioners who specialize in taxation. They can represent taxpayers before the IRS in all matters related to tax²².
• Tax Attorneys: Tax attorneys are lawyers who specialize in tax law. They can provide legal advice and representation in complex tax matters².

Finding a Qualified Accountant

If you decide to hire an accountant, it's crucial to find someone qualified and trustworthy. Here are some tips:

1. Ask for a PTIN: The IRS requires anyone who prepares or assists in preparing federal tax returns for compensation to have a preparer tax identification number (PTIN)²⁴.
2. Require a CPA, Law License, or Enrolled Agent Designation: Look for a credentialed preparer who is also a certified public accountant (CPA), licensed attorney, or enrolled agent (EA)²⁴.
3. Look for Memberships in Professional Organizations: Membership in a professional organization is a good sign, as most have codes of ethics, professional conduct requirements, and various certification programs²⁴.
4. Do a Background Search: Check the preparer or firm's reputation with the Better Business Bureau (BBB). You can also dig deeper into your preparer's background, depending on their specific title²⁴.
5. Check the Preparer's Qualifications: Use the IRS Directory of Federal Tax Return Preparers with Credentials and Select Qualifications to find a qualified tax preparer²⁵.
6. Check the Preparer's History: Ask the local Better Business Bureau about the preparer. Check for disciplinary actions and the license status for credentialed preparers²⁵.
7. Ask About Service Fees: Avoid tax return preparers who base fees on a percentage of the refund or who boast bigger refunds than their competition²⁵.
8. Ask to E-file: To avoid pandemic-related paper delays, taxpayers should ask their preparer to file electronically and choose direct deposit²⁵.
9. Make Sure the Preparer Is Available: Taxpayers may want to contact their tax return preparer after this year's April 18 due date²⁵.
10. Provide Records and Receipts: Good preparers will ask to see a taxpayer's records and receipts. They'll ask questions to figure things like the total income, tax deductions, and credits²⁵.
11. Never Sign a Blank Return: Taxpayers should not use a tax return preparer who asks them to sign a blank tax form²⁵.
12. Review Before Signing: Before signing a tax return, the taxpayer should review it. They should ask questions if something is not clear. Taxpayers should feel comfortable with the accuracy of their return before they sign it²⁵.
13. Review Details About Any Refund: Taxpayers should confirm the routing and bank account number on their completed return if they're requesting direct deposit²⁵.
14. Ensure the Preparer Signs the Return and Includes Their PTIN: All paid tax return preparers must have a Preparer Tax Identification number. By law, paid preparers must sign returns and include their PTIN on the return they file²⁵.

Mitigating Risks with Tax Software

If you opt for tax software, be aware of the potential risks and take steps to mitigate them:

• Data Security: Choose software with strong security measures like encryption and multi-factor authentication⁷.
• Accuracy: Double-check all data entry and review your return carefully before filing⁸.
• Understand Your Finances: Don't rely solely on the software. Take the time to understand your income, expenses, and deductions⁸.
• Seek Help When Needed: Don't hesitate to consult a tax professional if you have questions or encounter issues⁶.

Conclusion: A Confident Decision

Choosing between tax software and an accountant is a personal decision based on your individual needs and circumstances. By weighing the pros and cons, considering biblical principles, and taking steps to mitigate risks, you can approach tax season with confidence and peace of mind. Remember, whether you choose software or a professional, the goal is to be a faithful steward of your resources and fulfill your obligations with integrity¹⁸.

Ultimately, the decision of whether to use tax software or hire an accountant requires prayerful discernment and a careful assessment of your own abilities and resources. May God grant you wisdom and guidance as you navigate this important financial responsibility.

Works cited

1. Best Tax Software of 2025 - NerdWallet, accessed February 16, 2025, https://www.nerdwallet.com/p/best/taxes/tax-software
2. Turbotax vs. Accountant: When Should You Hire a CPA? - Above the Canopy, accessed February 16, 2025, https://www.abovethecanopy.us/turbotax-vs-accountant/
3. The Benefits and Drawbacks of Tax Software vs. Professional Help, accessed February 16, 2025, https://taxlawadvocates.com/the-benefits-and-drawbacks-of-tax-software-vs-professional-help/
4. Pros and Cons of Using Tax Preparation Software: TurboTax vs. a CPA - Cogneesol, accessed February 16, 2025, https://www.cogneesol.com/blog/tax-preparation-software-turbotax-vs-cpa
5. Best Tax Software for Small Business for 2025 - Investopedia, accessed February 16, 2025, https://www.investopedia.com/the-best-tax-software-for-small-business-8780637
6. Comparing DIY Tax Software vs. Professional Accountants | Taxfyle, accessed February 16, 2025, https://www.taxfyle.com/blog/comparing-diy-tax-software-vs-professional-accountants
7. Tax preparation automation: What businesses need to know - Stripe, accessed February 16, 2025, https://stripe.com/resources/more/tax-preparation-automation-what-businesses-need-to-know
8. Is tax preparation software worth it? Here's what some experts think - CBS News, accessed February 16, 2025, https://www.cbsnews.com/news/is-tax-preparation-software-worth-it-heres-what-some-experts-think/
9. When to Hire a CPA: Pros and Cons for Taxes - Business.com, accessed February 16, 2025, https://www.business.com/articles/hire-accountant-for-taxes/
10. The Pros and Cons of Hiring a Professional Tax Preparer - Good Financial Cents®, accessed February 16, 2025, https://www.goodfinancialcents.com/the-pros-and-cons-of-hiring-a-professional-tax-preparer/
11. What is the Average Cost of Tax Preparation by a CPA? - Bench Accounting, accessed February 16, 2025, https://www.bench.co/blog/tax-tips/average-cost-tax-prep-cpa
12. The Pros and Cons of Hiring a Professional Tax Preparer - Cook & Co. Tax Advisors, accessed February 16, 2025, https://cookco.us/news/the-pros-and-cons-of-hiring-a-professional-tax-preparer/
13. FreeTaxUSA® Customer Reviews, accessed February 16, 2025, https://www.freetaxusa.com/reviews
14. TurboTax® Online 2024-2025 - Customer Reviews - Intuit, accessed February 16, 2025, https://turbotax.intuit.com/reviews/
15. Testimonials - What Our Clients Say - Straight Talk CPA, accessed February 16, 2025, https://www.straighttalkcpas.com/testimonials
16. Money Matters! A Christian Perspective on Financial Ethics | Board of Retirement, accessed February 16, 2025, https://boardofretirement.com/money-matters-a-christian-perspective-on-financial-ethics/
17. Heaven's Ledger: Decoding Christian Financial and Wealth Ethics - Abundant Life Church Coffs Harbour, accessed February 16, 2025, https://alc.net.au/heavens-ledger-decoding-christian-financial-ethics/
18. Biblical Financial Principles and 5 Practical Steps to Live by Them, accessed February 16, 2025, https://www.christianstewardshipnetwork.com/blog/2023/6/22/biblical-financial-principles-and-5-practical-steps-to-live-by-them
19. Biblical Principles on Financial Stewardship- White Paper | Grace Chapel, accessed February 16, 2025, https://www.gracechapel.org/white-papers/biblical-principles-on-financial-stewardship-white-paper/
20. Is Tithing a Tax Write Off in Tax Season? Understanding Taxes, Tax Deductibles, & Tithes - Does It Qualify for a Tax Deduction? - Paybee, accessed February 16, 2025, https://w.paybee.io/post/is-tithing-a-tax-write-off
21. The Tithe of Malachi 3:8-11 Was a Tax - David Anderson, accessed February 16, 2025, https://davidandersontheauthor.com/2021/09/28/the-tithe-of-malachi-38-11-was-a-tax/
22. Tax Software vs a Tax Professional: Which Should You Choose? | Kiplinger, accessed February 16, 2025, https://www.kiplinger.com/taxes/tax-software-vs-a-tax-professional-which-to-choose
23. Should I use an Accountant or TurboTax? - Straight Talk CPAs, accessed February 16, 2025, https://www.straighttalkcpas.com/use-accountant-turbotax
24. How to Find the Best Tax Preparer Near You - NerdWallet, accessed February 16, 2025, https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/taxes/how-to-find-best-tax-preparer-near
25. Tips to help taxpayers hire a reputable tax preparer | Internal Revenue Service, accessed February 16, 2025, https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/tips-to-help-taxpayers-hire-a-reputable-tax-preparer