March 8, 2025

Is the 30% Housing Rule Obsolete?

Is the 30% Rule for Housing Costs Still Wise Today?

The 30% rule has long been a cornerstone of personal finance, advising that no more than 30% of one's gross monthly income should be allocated to housing expenses. This includes rent or mortgage payments, utilities, and, for homeowners, property taxes and insurance. However, with the current economic realities and evolving financial priorities, many are questioning the continued wisdom of this guideline. In this blog post, we'll delve into the 30% rule, examining its origins, its relevance in today's world, and alternative approaches to consider. So Is the 30% Housing Rule Obsolete? Let's take a closer look.

Check out the full podcast episode:

What is the 30% Rule?

The 30% rule suggests that individuals should dedicate a maximum of 30% of their gross monthly income (before taxes) towards housing costs. For renters, this typically includes rent and utilities. For homeowners, it encompasses mortgage payments, property taxes, homeowner's insurance, and utilities. This rule stems from the Brooke Amendment to the Housing Act of 1969, which initially capped public housing rent at 25% of a tenant's annual income. This cap was later raised to 30% by Congress in 1981¹. The 30% rule aims to help individuals maintain a balanced budget, ensuring they have sufficient funds for other essential expenses, savings, and unexpected financial challenges².

Why the 30% Rule Might Be Outdated

While the 30% rule offers a general framework for budgeting, it may not be a suitable guideline for everyone in today's dynamic economic environment. Here's why:

Outdated Origins: The 30% rule was established in a different economic era, with different financial realities. It may not accurately reflect the financial obligations of today, such as 401(k) contributions, the significant burden of student loan debt, and the rising costs of childcare³. Furthermore, the rule was initially designed for public housing residents and may not be applicable to the broader population with diverse financial situations and goals.
Ignores Individual Circumstances: The rule fails to consider individual financial situations, such as varying levels of debt, savings goals, and personal priorities⁴. For instance, a high earner with minimal debt may comfortably afford to allocate more than 30% of their income to housing, while someone with a lower income and substantial debt may struggle to stay below this threshold⁵. Moreover, individuals with high medical expenses or significant financial dependents may need to adjust their housing budget accordingly.
Rising Housing Costs and Stagnant Wage Growth: In many regions, housing costs have skyrocketed, making it increasingly difficult to find affordable options within the 30% limit⁶. This challenge is compounded by the fact that wage growth has not kept pace with the rise in housing costs, further exacerbating affordability issues⁷.
Doesn't Account for Income Variations: The 30% rule applies a fixed percentage to all income levels, which may not be appropriate for both low and high earners⁴. For those with lower incomes, adhering to the 30% rule might leave insufficient funds for other necessities, while higher earners may find themselves with an unnecessarily restrictive housing budget.

Arguments for the 30% Rule

Despite the arguments against its universal applicability, the 30% rule offers some valuable benefits:

Simplicity: It provides a simple and easy-to-understand guideline for budgeting, especially for those new to managing their finances⁸.
Financial Discipline: It encourages individuals to prioritize their spending and avoid overspending on housing, promoting responsible financial behavior².
Flexibility: The 30% rule can be adjusted based on individual circumstances and financial goals². It serves as a starting point that can be adapted to fit different needs and priorities.
Reduces Financial Strain: By limiting housing costs, the rule can help individuals manage unexpected expenses, build a financial safety net, and avoid financial hardship².

How Much Do Americans Spend on Housing Today?

Despite the 30% guideline, a significant portion of Americans spend more than this on housing. According to a report from CardRates, nearly 8 in 10 Americans (76%) exceed the 30% threshold, with 53% spending more than half their monthly salary on housing⁷. The median rent in the U.S. is $1,967, which is above the recommended $1,864 for a household with the median income of $74,580⁶. On average, American households spend $24,298 per year on housing costs, representing 25.8% of their total average earnings⁹.

Impact of Rising Housing Costs on Household Budgets

Rising housing costs have a profound impact on household budgets, particularly for low- and middle-income families¹⁰. When a substantial portion of income is allocated to housing, it leaves less for other essential expenses, such as food, healthcare, transportation, and education¹¹. This can lead to financial strain, increased debt, and difficulty saving for the future¹². For lower-income renters, high housing costs can severely limit their ability to afford other necessities. In 2022, the median residual income (the amount left after paying rent) for lower-income renters fell to a record low of $310 per month, far below what is needed to maintain an adequate standard of living¹³. This often forces them to make difficult choices, such as cutting back on essential expenses or living in overcrowded or substandard housing conditions.

Furthermore, the home price to median income ratio in the U.S. has been on the rise, reaching 7.56 in 2023. This means that the median home price is now 7.56 times the median household income, surpassing the previous peak of 6.8 in 2006 during the housing bubble¹⁴. This trend highlights the growing challenge of housing affordability and the increasing financial burden it places on households.

The Economic Impact of Affordable Housing

While affordable housing is crucial for individual financial well-being, it also has significant positive impacts on the broader economy and community well-being. Increased access to affordable housing can lead to greater tax generation, job creation, economic development opportunities, improved job retention and productivity, and a reduction in inequality¹⁵. When families have access to stable and affordable housing, they have more disposable income to spend on goods and services, stimulating local economies. Moreover, businesses benefit from a more stable workforce and reduced employee turnover when housing costs are manageable.

Biblical Principles and Housing Costs

As Christians, our financial decisions should be guided by biblical principles. Here are some key principles to consider when evaluating housing costs:

God's Ownership: We are stewards of God's resources, including our finances. We should manage them responsibly and avoid excessive spending, recognizing that our homes and possessions ultimately belong to Him¹⁶.
Contentment: We should be content with what we have and avoid the trap of materialism and greed, recognizing that true wealth lies not in possessions but in our relationship with God¹⁷. Prioritizing giving and focusing on God's priorities can help us avoid the temptation to overspend on housing and find contentment in His provision¹⁸.
Wise Planning: We should plan for the future and make informed financial decisions, seeking God's wisdom and guidance in our choices¹⁶. This includes creating a budget, considering long-term financial goals, and avoiding unnecessary debt.
Generosity: We should prioritize giving and support the work of the church and those in need, recognizing that our financial blessings are meant to be shared¹⁶.

Alternative Guidelines for Housing Costs

While the 30% rule provides a starting point, it's important to consider alternative guidelines and personalize your approach to budgeting for housing:

The 50/30/20 Budget: This approach allocates 50% of your after-tax income to needs (including housing), 30% to wants, and 20% to savings and debt repayment⁶. This framework provides a balanced approach to managing your finances and ensures that you prioritize both essential expenses and financial goals.
The 28/36 Rule: This guideline suggests spending no more than 28% of your gross income on housing expenses (excluding utilities) and no more than 36% on total debt²⁰. This rule is often used by mortgage lenders to assess borrowers' ability to repay a loan and can be a helpful tool for evaluating your overall debt burden.
Financial Order of Operations (FOO): This framework prioritizes financial goals in a specific order: giving, investing, eliminating debt, and then housing²¹. This approach emphasizes building a strong financial foundation by prioritizing giving and investing before allocating funds to housing.
Personalized Budgeting: Create a detailed budget based on your specific income, expenses, and financial goals⁵. This involves tracking your spending, identifying areas where you can reduce expenses, and allocating funds according to your priorities.
Smart Strategies for Affordable Home Buying: When considering homeownership, explore strategies to make it more affordable. This could include:
- Considering Adjustable-Rate Mortgages (ARMs): ARMs typically offer lower initial interest rates than fixed-rate mortgages, which can help reduce your monthly payments in the early years of homeownership²².
- Being Hands-on with Home Inspections: Actively participate in your home inspection to gain a thorough understanding of the property's condition and potential maintenance needs²². This can help you avoid unexpected repair costs and make informed decisions about your purchase.

Impact of Housing Costs on Other Financial Goals

Housing costs significantly impact other financial goals, such as saving, investing, and giving. High housing costs can limit your ability to save for emergencies, invest for the future, and contribute to charitable causes²³. By prioritizing affordable housing, you free up resources for other financial priorities and long-term goals²⁴. This allows you to diversify your investments, potentially achieving higher returns and building long-term wealth.

Conclusion

The 30% rule for housing costs can be a helpful guideline, but it's crucial to evaluate its relevance in light of your individual circumstances, financial goals, and biblical principles⁸. It should be viewed as a starting point or "rule of thumb" rather than a strict rule. Consider alternative guidelines, create a personalized budget, and prioritize your spending to ensure you make wise financial decisions that align with your values and long-term objectives. Remember to seek God's wisdom in all your financial matters and strive to be a faithful steward of the resources He has entrusted to you.

As Christians, we are called to be wise stewards of our finances, balancing our desire for comfortable housing with our responsibility to manage our resources responsibly and prioritize giving. By seeking God's guidance and making informed decisions, we can find a balance that honors Him and supports our financial well-being.

Works cited

Affordable Housing, a definition - Front Porch Investments, accessed March 3, 2025, https://frontporchinvestments.org/news/words-matter.html
30% rule for housing | First Financial Bank, accessed March 3, 2025, https://www.bankatfirst.com/personal/discover/flourish/thirty-percent-rule.html
Rent Budget Dilemma? Ditch the 30% Rule - A Smarter Approach - Paidly, accessed March 3, 2025, https://meetpaidly.com/blog/30-rule-smart-rent-budgeting-personalized-approach
How Much Should I Spend on Rent? Ignore the '30% Rule' - Earnest, accessed March 3, 2025, https://www.earnest.com/blog/rent-and-the-30-percent-rule/
Is the 30% Rule outdated or reasonable? : r/personalfinance - Reddit, accessed March 3, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/personalfinance/comments/12gtz7k/is_the_30_rule_outdated_or_reasonable/
Affordable Housing in 2024: Navigating the 30% Rule in a Challenging Market - Payactiv, accessed March 3, 2025, https://www.payactiv.com/financial-learning/affordable-housing-in-2024-navigating-the-30-rule-in-a-challenging-market/
The 30% Rule for Housing Costs is Ignored By Almost 8 in 10 Americans — Is it Time to Revisit This Common Budgeting Technique? | Moneywise, accessed March 3, 2025, https://moneywise.com/real-estate/30-rule-for-housing-costs-is-ignored-by-almost-8-in-10-americans
Spend no more than 30% on housing? Not necessarily, Northeastern household finance experts say, accessed March 3, 2025, https://news.northeastern.edu/2024/01/31/30-percent-rule-housing/
www.self.inc, accessed March 3, 2025, https://www.self.inc/info/percentage-of-income-spent-on-housing/#:~:text=American%20households%20spend%20an%20average,25.8%25%20of%20total%20average%20earnings.
Understanding Cost of Living Increase: Impacts and Insights, accessed March 3, 2025, https://unitedwaynca.org/cost-of-living-increase/
Rent, House Prices, and Demographics | U.S. Department of the Treasury, accessed March 3, 2025, https://home.treasury.gov/news/featured-stories/rent-house-prices-and-demographics
Increasingly Debt-Strapped Consumers Concerned About Rising Housing-Related Costs, accessed March 3, 2025, https://www.fanniemae.com/research-and-insights/increasingly-debt-strapped-consumers-concerned-about-rising-housing-related-costs
High Housing Costs Are Consuming Household Incomes - Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies, accessed March 3, 2025, https://www.jchs.harvard.edu/blog/high-housing-costs-are-consuming-household-incomes
What Percentage of Income is Spent on Housing? Statistics | Self.inc, accessed March 3, 2025, https://www.self.inc/info/percentage-of-income-spent-on-housing/
The impact of housing affordability on the economy | Cost of Home - Habitat for Humanity, accessed March 3, 2025, https://www.habitat.org/costofhome/housing-affordability-and-economy
7 Biblical Principles for Financial Stewardship: Navigating Finances with Faith, accessed March 3, 2025, https://biblestudyforall.org/7-biblical-principles-for-financial-stewardship-navigating-finances-with-faith/
Biblical Financial Principles and 5 Practical Steps to Live by Them, accessed March 3, 2025, https://www.christianstewardshipnetwork.com/blog/2023/6/22/biblical-financial-principles-and-5-practical-steps-to-live-by-them
Biblical Budgeting Principles: Aligning Your Finances with God's Priorities | OneAscent, accessed March 3, 2025, https://oneascent.com/biblical-budgeting-principles-aligning-your-finances-with-gods-priorities/
Biblical Principles on Financial Stewardship- White Paper | Grace Chapel, accessed March 3, 2025, https://www.gracechapel.org/white-papers/biblical-principles-on-financial-stewardship-white-paper/
Making Room for Housing in Your Budget | Ephrata National Bank, accessed March 3, 2025, https://www.epnb.com/insights/making-room-for-housing-in-your-budget/
FOO - Your Ultimate Guide to The Financial Order of Operations - Money Guy, accessed March 3, 2025, https://moneyguy.com/article/foo/
Smart Strategies for Affordable Home Buying and Moving for Families - One Messy Bun, accessed March 3, 2025, https://onemessybun.com/blogs/omb-blog/smart-strategies-for-affordable-home-buying-and-moving-for-families
Personal Financial Management and Housing Affordability - Evergreen Investments, accessed March 3, 2025, https://evergreeninvestments.co/blog/personal-financial-management-and-housing-affordability/
Impact investing: The continued resilience of US affordable housing investments - Nuveen, accessed March 3, 2025, https://www.nuveen.com/global/insights/real-estate/impact-investing-the-continued-resilience-of-us-affordable-housing-investments

Ralph V. Estep, Jr.

Christian Financial Consulting

Ralph V. Estep, Jr. is a highly accomplished professional with a diverse background in finance, accounting, technology, and entrepreneurship. As the principal at Saggio Management Group, Inc., he has demonstrated exceptional leadership and expertise in various roles throughout his career.

Ralph's educational journey began at St. Mark's High School in Newark, Delaware before attending the University of Nebraska where he was an esteemed member of the Cornhusker Marching Band and had the privilege of performing at the Florida Citrus Bowl in Orlando.

Continuing his pursuit of knowledge and excellence, Ralph earned a Bachelor of Science Degree in Accounting from the University of Delaware. He further expanded his academic achievements by obtaining a Master's in Business Administration from Wilmington University.

Throughout his professional journey, Ralph has been recognized for his outstanding accomplishments and commitment to excellence. He is a member of prestigious organizations such as the Golden Key National Honor Society and Beta Gamma Sigma International Business Honor Society.

With an extensive range of professional designations including Licensed Public Accountant (LPA), Accredited Business Accountant (ABA), Accredited Tax Advisor (ATA), Accredited Tax Preparer (ATP), and Internal Revenue Service Registered Tax Preparer (RTRP), Ralph possesses comprehensive expertise in tax preparation and financial management.

Beyond his impressive qualifications, Ralph has actively engaged with various community programs as bo… Read More

How Can You Practice Generosity Without Breaking the Bank?

Can You Truly Live Generously on a Tight Budget? Many Christians wonder how they can live generously when their finances are tight. It can be challenging to balance giving with saving and paying bills, especially when living paycheck to paycheck. H…

Should You Claim Social Security Now or Later?

Are You Sacrificing Your Future by Taking Social Security Too Soon? Retirement. It's a time many of us dream about – a time to relax, enjoy hobbies, and spend more time with loved ones. But with retirement come important financial decisions 1…